The Fifth Circuit has not declared that immigrants have no due-process rights. It has produced something more administratively sophisticated: a decision recognizing the protection while refusing the particular hearing the people locked up were asking for.
On Friday, the full appeals court rejected a constitutional right to individualized bond hearings for the unadmitted immigrants covered by the detention policy before it, Law & Crime reports. Those hearings would let them argue about matters such as dangerousness and flight risk while removal proceedings continue.
The majority's reasoning treats those individual facts as irrelevant to detention under the statute it applied. The legal category does the work. The person may keep the facts, although they apparently will not be needed at this window.
Imagine a customer-service desk that proudly displays its commitment to hearing from you, then explains that your particular circumstances are not among its supported file formats. That is aggravating when the subject is a damaged toaster. Here, the subject is someone's physical freedom.
The Daily Heckler: five or six selected stories.
Political satire for your morning inbox.
A bond hearing is not an automatic release. It is an opportunity to make an argument about release. That distinction is the point, not a loophole to be filled with a stern announcement about enforcing the law. Requiring a decision-maker to consider a person is not the same as requiring a decision-maker to agree with them.
The court's answer is that the Constitution does not require these additional proceedings beyond what Congress provided for this category. Critics can reject that answer without pretending the judges erased the Fifth Amendment or ruled on every immigrant's circumstances. Precision makes the objection stronger: a protection can remain formally present while the available way to use it gets smaller.
For the government, categories are wonderfully tidy. They fit in headings. They do not interrupt to explain where they live, whom they care for or why a label fails to describe a life.
The untidy part is the human being. A hearing is where that person gets to become more than the heading.


Comments
Have something to say? Give this story a heckle.
Comment Rules
Argue the point. Add a joke. No threats, harassment, hate speech, spam, private personal information or unsupported accusations. First-time comments and comments with links are moderated. Full Comment Rules
Loading comments…
Questions or deletion requests? Contact Us. We retain comments and moderation records until removed. Only hashed email identifiers are stored for comment accounts.