The difficult thing about keeping a secret inside Google is that Google also works in the next room.
Ars Technica reported October 23 on an October 16 privacy-policy clarification: information shared through opt-in Personal Intelligence can inform personalized AI search, including advertising. Google says ads are not based directly on users’ Gmail inboxes or Photos libraries, sensitive information is excluded, and the clarification does not change how it handles users’ data with advertising partners.
The important word is directly. It has a demanding job. It must stand between a private email and a commercially useful insight while the insight walks around it.
Picture a hotel with a very discreet concierge. You voluntarily tell him your travel plans so he can help arrange your day. He promises not to hand your itinerary to the gift shop. Excellent. The gift shop will merely be made more relevant to the day he has arranged for you.
The Daily Heckler: five or six selected stories.
Political satire for your morning inbox.
Nobody has sold your suitcase. Why would they? It is much more useful to know where you are taking it.
The opt-in matters. This is not a claim that Google has switched on blanket advertising scans of everyone’s inbox, or that the Gemini app itself currently carries ads. You have to connect the services. The difficulty is that an invitation to make an assistant more helpful is a rather friendlier proposition than an invitation to make the sales floor better informed.
A truly considerate interface would let the departments introduce themselves separately. Here is the assistant who will help you remember things. Here is the advertising operation that would also appreciate you remembering things, preferably things available in several colors with expedited delivery.
Instead, the reader of a privacy policy must follow the information through a corporate building, checking which room it has entered and what its job title is now.
Your email is still private. Please congratulate its insights on their transfer to marketing.


Comments
Have something to say? Give this story a heckle.
Comment Rules
Argue the point. Add a joke. No threats, harassment, hate speech, spam, private personal information or unsupported accusations. First-time comments and comments with links are moderated. Full Comment Rules
Loading comments…
Questions or deletion requests? Contact Us. We retain comments and moderation records until removed. Only hashed email identifiers are stored for comment accounts.