Suppose the government declines to enforce a pollution law. Congress has provided a useful backup: citizens can sue. Donald Trump’s administration proposed an improvement. The government that declined to act would also decide whether anybody else could.
That is a beautifully closed system. The complaint about the off switch goes through the off switch.
According to Ars Technica, federal judge Debra Brown rejected that argument Tuesday in the NAACP’s case against the company now called SpaceXAI. The suit alleges unpermitted gas turbines at its Memphis data center and seeks pollution controls and penalties. This ruling preserves the lawsuit; it does not decide those allegations.
The administration’s attempted shortcut depended on a real feature of the Clean Air Act. Government enforcement can sometimes displace a citizen suit. If officials are already making a polluter comply, a second case may interfere. Trump’s team wanted the same courtesy while declining to enforce the law. Apparently, the two activities are interchangeable provided the official stationery survives.
The Daily Heckler: five or six selected stories.
Political satire for your morning inbox.
The administration also argued that imposing civil penalties belonged to executive power. Brown rejected its attempt to find that exclusive right in the statute. The fines would be payable to the Treasury, which makes the objection especially choice: citizens might help enforce the law and send the government money, without first securing its permission to be useful.
Brown noted another difficulty: the law also permits suits against the EPA administrator for failing to enforce it. Requiring the administrator’s blessing would turn that provision into a very elaborate suggestion box with a shredder underneath.
Congress considered giving the EPA control over citizen suits in 1990. It did not adopt the amendment. The administration was effectively seeking the benefits of a legislative victory without the inconvenience of having one. For an industry impatient with air-permit requirements, even the missing law was expected to get out of the way.
Then the government appealed before Brown issued her written order, assuming she had barred its intervention altogether. She hadn’t. She rejected dismissal and left room to intervene for another purpose.
The administration now has until October 23 to explain what that purpose is. After all this effort to stop citizens from having their day in court, Trump’s lawyers have been offered one of their own. They just need something to say besides “court cancelled.”


Comments (0)
Have something to say? Give this story a heckle.
Comment Rules
Argue the point. Add a joke. No threats, harassment, hate speech, spam, private personal information or unsupported accusations. First-time comments and comments with links are moderated. Full Comment Rules
No approved comments yet. Give this story its first heckle.