The social media industry is suing New York because a warning might interrupt your scrolling. At last, the people who built autoplay have discovered that unsolicited content can be fucking annoying.
NetChoice, whose members include Meta, Google and TikTok, says the state's warning-label law violates the First Amendment by forcing platforms to carry a government message. A judge blocked a similar Colorado law; its appeal is pending. There is a real constitutional dispute here, inconveniently attached to this particular collection of concerned interruptions experts.
New York's law covers features including infinite scrolling, autoplay and algorithmic feeds. The warning acknowledges possible benefits for young users and says excessive use may be associated with significant mental-health harms. Even the warning has stopped to consider both sides. Autoplay has already moved on.
The Daily Heckler: five or six selected stories.
Political satire for your morning inbox.
NetChoice describes the law as designed to “block, burden, and browbeat” users. That is quite a workout for a notice containing the word may. The industry's alarm about the warning is considerably less qualified than the warning about the industry.
The law, scheduled to take effect January 1, requires a notice at sign-in and again after multiple hours, without a bypass. That later reminder is especially menacing: it reaches someone who has already spent hours demonstrating that access to the platform is proceeding extremely well.
NetChoice says repeated notices block protected speech. Perhaps the court will agree.
But censorship that lets you scroll for hours before checking on you has a remarkably generous free trial.


Comments (0)
Have something to say? Give this story a heckle.
Comment Rules
Argue the point. Add a joke. No threats, harassment, hate speech, spam, private personal information or unsupported accusations. First-time comments and comments with links are moderated. Full Comment Rules
No approved comments yet. Give this story its first heckle.